Ah, the infamous scene. Snape calls Lily a Mudblood in their youth. Lily never spoke to him again. Is that something a future baby-daddy does?
No. That’s the moment you blow up a friendship with a bomb. You don’t insult the mother of your future child in public unless you’re starring in a bad soap opera.
Plus, Snape spent the rest of his life groveling. If Harry were his son, you think he’d spend six years bullying him in class? “Dad of the Year” material, right there.
The Physical Evidence (Or Lack Thereof)
Look at Harry: messy black hair, his father’s exact face, and a fit of heroism that screams Gryffindor. Snape is sallow-skinned, stringy-haired, and oily enough to fry chips.
Even Petunia admits Harry looks “just like James.” If there’s one person who might have wanted to claim Snape as the father, it’s Petunia. She hates James. She also hates magic. But she never even hints at it.
And what about the Elder Wand thing? Harry has a deep connection to Voldemort’s wand. Not because of Snape. Because of a Horcrux. The theory falls apart faster than a Dobby-made casserole.
Ist Severus Snape Harry Potters Vater
